Posted by
TLM on Saturday, May 31, 2008 9:37:34 PM
Why do they cling to their guns? "They" being those mythical hard working socially conservative Middle Americans. You know, the ones liberal Democrats would more openly disparage if they didn't need their votes. Barack Obama and his friends offer us an economic explanation for the phenomena of the gun obsessed lower classes. Unable to adapt to new economic trends, they are stuck in a rut, ridin' shotgun on the last stagecoach to Nowheresville. With their stagnating jobs based on old industries, manufacturing, farming etc, the poor down trodden blue collar masses have been rendered witless, unable to adapt to the new high tech economy. So "they cling to what they know" says Obama. Religion, xenophobia and their guns. Perhaps re-education camps would be of help to them, but then they have already proven themselves averse to the benefits of an education. Better jobs could change them for the better, curing them of their affliction, their addiction to guns. Alas, for them, change is not something you can believe in, it is something to be afraid of. And in their fear they circle the wagons, guns pointing outward at the world and await their fate.
I apologize if I have understated the liberal Left's argument here regarding gun ownership in America. In any case, it is preposterous. When Obama's gun gaffe in San Francisco was spilled to the public a few months ago, the initial uproar was directed at the dismissive attitude toward certain Americans implicit in his statements. He countered by saying he meant no disrespect. He was merely offering an explanation, an economic one, for their odd behavior. This led to a diagnosis of subacute Marxism by some pundits, possibly terminal. He may not have intended to be dismissive, but Obama does appear to believe socio-economic status determines certain behaviors like gun ownership, not voting for him, and retaining certain traditions and values. Lost in all the hoopla, I believe, is that what he said was plainly wrong, and betrays his profound ignorance of guns and the people who own them.
What do we know about guns in America? Guns are common, being found in approximately one in two households overall. Rates of gun ownership correlate strongly with where a person lives, being higher the further away from urban areas you go. Social surveys confirm this. However, very little else is known for certain about gun ownership in America. I doubt, for example, reliable data exist for how many Americans actually shoot their guns or how often. Blue collar jobs are also relatively more common in the same non-urban areas where gun ownership is high. But this is a demographic association not a cause and effect relationship. People in non-urban areas in this country have always owned guns, through good times and bad. Economic assumptions about gun ownership are ridiculous for a lot of reasons, not the least of which is we know so little about this common American trait.
There's another reason they hang onto their guns, one that tells us a lot about ourselves and our country. One Senator Obama would do well to heed. (Caveat: True gun nuts may now be excused as what follows is somewhat simplistic. I don't need the email overload).
Among other things, guns represent to their owners a traditional American value, one that used to be universally accepted in this country. That value is still expressed in phrases like "well made", "made to last", "made in America". But sadly, those phrases no longer ring true in our country. Picture a guy who's been working on a Ford Motor Company assembly line for forty years. Do you think he believes his company's "Quality Is Job 1" slogan? Toyota usurped that reality a long time ago. So he goes home at night and cleans his Winchester Model 70 bolt action deer rifle handed down from his father. The gun's weathered and beaten, but the parts are original and it still shoots true. Also, it's worth more now than when it was initially purchased. Why not sell it for the money? In part because it was made by Americans who understood the value of things made to last. He wishes he worked for a company that still understands that basic American ideal.
Guns embody such concepts more than any other product made in this country. Don't believe me? Name an item that is manufactured in America, mass produced, sold to millions of people, which with little upkeep can easily last a hundred years or more. Guns are the antithesis our modern disposable mindset, which itself is a result of an economy predicated on expendability. They have always been built to last. Quality, durability and dependability -- what ever happened to those American values, Senator Obama? That's why people who own guns hang on to them. Sad to say, Winchester Repeating Arms Company closed its plant in New Haven two years ago. Is Ford or GM next?